Adulteration in chili flakes and other spices cannot be reliably detected by sight or smell; dyes, starch and foreign plant material each need their own analysis. At intake, a batch's composition is compared with a reference known to be correct, and a batch that deviates is settled in the laboratory by targeted testing. Türkiye's Food Codex spice communiqué already bans fillers such as starch, semolina and bran, so a buyer's job is to verify that its own batch respects that ban.
What do the rules limit in chili flakes and spices?
Article 5 of the Turkish Food Codex Communiqué on Spices (No. 2022/7) sets product characteristics. These criteria can go straight into a purchase specification, including for spices bought from Türkiye:
| Criterion | Limit | Article |
|---|---|---|
| Starch, semolina, milling by-products, bran and similar fillers | Not allowed (starch naturally in the product excepted) | 5(d) |
| Added edible vegetable oil in chili flakes and isot | Max 6% by weight | 5(h) |
| Salt in chili flakes and isot | Max 7% | 5(h) |
| Seeds and seed fragments | Max 40% by mass; 2% in seedless ("silk") flakes | 5(h), 5(ı) |
| Total fat, on dry matter | Max 18%; 9% in seedless flakes | 5(h), 5(ı) |
| The plant's own stem and twig pieces | Max 1% by mass | 5(i) |
| Added oil in ground red pepper | Max 1% by weight | 5(ğ) |
| Lead chromate test on ground turmeric | Must be negative | 5(e) |
For colourants the communiqué points to the Food Additives Regulation. A text dated 13 October 2023 replaced the 2013 regulation.
What fraud actually turns up?
The most thorough public data comes from the EU control plan coordinated by the European Commission and analysed by its Joint Research Centre (JRC). According to results published in 2021, about 10,000 analyses were run on 1,885 samples from 21 EU member states plus Norway and Switzerland, and 17% of samples were suspicious. By product:
- Oregano: 48% (mostly olive leaves)
- Pepper: 17%
- Cumin: 14%
- Turmeric and saffron: 11%
- Paprika and chili: 6%
Most suspicious samples contained undeclared plant material. Unauthorised dyes appeared in 2% of spice samples, and one sample held a high level of lead chromate. These figures are not a market estimate, and "suspicious" does not mean proven fraud, but they do show what to look for.
In Türkiye the place to look is the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry's list of adulterated foods. Records visible on 7 November 2026, covering 1 June to 27 October 2026, show six entries in the spice group: food dye in sumac twice, foreign matter in oregano three times and in another spice once. No product named as chili flakes appears in that window, although 2026 press coverage of the list did report dye findings in chili flakes and ground red pepper. The list is a snapshot; a product's absence does not mean the risk is absent.
Which test catches which fraud?
| Fraud | Visible at intake | What settles it |
|---|---|---|
| Fat-soluble synthetic dye (such as the Sudan group) | Deviation from reference profile; colour alone proves nothing | Targeted chromatography (LC-UV, LC-MS) |
| Starch, semolina, bran | Deviation from reference profile | Microscopy and starch determination |
| Foreign plant material (such as olive leaf in oregano) | Sorting, profile deviation | Extraneous matter and total ash, microscopy, DNA |
| Excess seed, stem, salt or oil | Batch appearance, profile drift | Sorting, salt and fat determination |
| Lead chromate (turmeric) | Not visible | The communiqué's test, elemental analysis |
Dyes deserve a separate note. In a 2005 review, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) concluded that unauthorised dyes including Sudan I-IV and Para Red are genotoxic and/or carcinogenic, and noted that they reached EU food mainly through imported spices and ingredients. On the method side, one liquid chromatography method developed on chili powder reported detection limits of 0.02 to 0.04 mg/kg. Expecting that sensitivity from a profile comparison would be wrong. The comparison tells you which batch to look at; targeted analysis names the dye and its amount.
Two limits are worth keeping in mind. A targeted method finds only what is on its panel, so a dye outside the panel will not appear in the result. The JRC did not rely on one test either: it treated samples failing ISO limits for extraneous matter and total ash as suspicious and used biomarker tests as supporting evidence. A profile comparison, for its part, is only as strong as its reference, because region, harvest and processing all shift the profile. We cover this in how to build a reference library.
How should a buyer set up intake?
For meat, ready meal and sauce manufacturers, spices are a small-volume ingredient that passes straight into the finished product. A workable setup:
- Write the specification. Put limits, dye and filler expectations, and a batch number requirement into the contract.
- Read the certificate of analysis by parameter. If it has no dye screen, it says nothing about dyes. See our certificate of analysis checklist.
- Prioritise ground and crushed forms. Fillers and foreign plant material cannot be picked out by eye in these forms.
- Set frequency by risk. Measure more often for new suppliers, prices clearly below market, changed source regions and batches with complaints.
- Sample properly. A product that varies from sack to sack is not represented by a single-point sample; keep a retained sample. Details in sampling validity.
- Stop a non-conforming batch. Under Article 24 of Türkiye's Law No. 5996, adulterated product may not be processed or placed on the market. Hold the batch until the laboratory result is clear.
Where does Molevex fit?
Molevex adds nothing to the spice; it measures the batch's own composition and compares it with a sample you know to be correct. An added or substituted component shows up as a difference in that comparison, a sample that does not match the declaration is taken up in the laboratory, and the result is finalised there. Each result is stored against its batch. Molevex does not replace official controls. See the food page for sector detail.
Sources
- Turkish Food Codex Communiqué on Spices (No. 2022/7), Official Gazette, 19 April 2022, No. 31814 (FAOLEX copy, in Turkish)
- Turkish Food Codex Food Additives Regulation, Official Gazette, 13 October 2023 (in Turkish)
- Law No. 5996 on Veterinary Services, Plant Health, Food and Feed (in Turkish)
- Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, list of imitated or adulterated foods (in Turkish)
- European Commission, herbs and spices coordinated control plan 2019-2021
- European Commission, announcement of herbs and spices results, 23 November 2021
- JRC, Results of an EU wide coordinated control plan (EUR 30877 EN), 2021
- EFSA, EFSA reviews toxicological data of illegal dyes in food, 12 September 2005
- Adjei et al., Sudan dyes in chilli pepper powder, Heliyon, 2020


