How do you carry out a food fraud vulnerability assessment?

BRCGS, FSSC 22000 and IFS Food require a documented vulnerability assessment but prescribe no single method. The steps of an assessment that holds up at audit, from team to review.

A food fraud vulnerability assessment (often called VACCP in the industry) is a risk assessment that scores how exposed each raw material is to adulteration and substitution against documented criteria, and sets control measures for the vulnerabilities found to be significant. BRCGS Food Safety Issue 9, FSSC 22000 and IFS Food Version 8 all require one, but none prescribes a single method. In practice there are seven steps: team, information sources, raw material list, risk factors, scoring, measures and review. What the auditor looks at is not the name of the method but whether the criteria are defined and the outcome is tied to measures.

What exactly do the standards require?

All three standards rest on the same Global Food Safety Initiative (GFSI) framework. The GFSI Benchmarking Requirements version 2024 call for a documented food fraud management plan specifying the measures implemented to mitigate the public health risks from identified vulnerabilities (FSM 8.2), review of the plan on a regular basis or when a new vulnerability is established (FSM 8.3), and appropriate knowledge and expertise in developing the plan (FSM 8.5).

StandardClauseScopeReview
BRCGS Food Safety Issue 9 (August 2022)5.4.1-5.4.4All food raw materials or groups of raw materialsAnnually and on defined triggers
FSSC 22000 Version 62.5.4.1 and 2.5.4.2Processes and products within the organisation's scopePlan kept up to date
FSSC 22000 Version 7 (May 2026)2.5.4 and ISO 22002-100:2025 clause 16.3Processes and products within the organisation's scopePlan kept up to date
IFS Food Version 84.20Raw materials, packaging and outsourced processesAt least once in 12 months and on significant changes

FSSC 22000 is in transition. In Version 6, 2.5.4.1 requires a documented vulnerability assessment based on a defined methodology, with mitigation measures for significant vulnerabilities, and 2.5.4.2 requires a plan based on the assessment's output that specifies the mitigation measures and verification procedures. In Version 7, released on 1 May 2026, the base requirement sits in clause 16.3 of ISO 22002-100:2025; FSSC 2.5.4 adds that the assessment and plan are developed and maintained by competent personnel, and that the plan is supported by the food safety management system, complies with legislation and is kept up to date. According to the FSSC FAQ, Version 6 audits can be carried out until 30 April 2027. In both versions, organisations in food chain category FII (brokering and trading) must ensure their suppliers have a food fraud mitigation plan in place.

BRCGS is revising the standard as Issue 10; audits are currently carried out against Issue 9. Confirm with your certification body which version you will be audited against.

Step 1: Who should carry out the assessment?

BRCGS 5.4.1 requires the person or team carrying out the assessment to understand potential food fraud risks, the raw materials used on site and the principles of vulnerability assessment. The FSSC guidance recommends a multidisciplinary team: security, legal, purchasing, production, R&D, regulatory affairs and quality. According to the guidance, this team may differ from the HACCP team, and external expertise may be used where needed. Purchasing matters here; it is the first to see changes in price and supply conditions.

Step 2: Which information sources should be monitored?

BRCGS 5.4.2 requires a process to access information on historical and developing threats in the supply chain, giving trade associations, government sources and private resource centres as examples. For a business operating in Türkiye, two official sources stand out:

  • Public announcements by the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry: the official page where products found to be adulterated or counterfeit are published.
  • The European Commission's monthly report on agri-food fraud suspicions: the Commission states that operators should carry out adequate vulnerability assessments to identify risks, and that the report provides generic information for this. The cases are cross-border "non-compliances with fraud suspicions"; in the assessment, suspicion and confirmed cases should be kept apart.

Record who monitors which source and how often.

Step 3: How are raw materials listed and grouped?

BRCGS requires the assessment for "all food raw materials or groups of raw materials". The FSSC guidance also allows similar materials to be grouped to start with; if a significant vulnerability appears within a group, that group is analysed further and in more depth. Coming from the same supplier is not a sufficient grouping criterion. Raw materials that are similar in price, fraud history and testability should sit in the same group. For example, the whole and ground forms of the same spice may deserve separate assessments; the IFS guideline also notes that risk rises with the level of processing.

Step 4: Which risk factors are scored?

The factors the standards list overlap to a large extent:

FactorBRCGS 5.4.3FSSC guidanceIFS guideline
Historical incidentsYesYesYes
Economic attractivenessYesYesYes (price, supply, claims)
Ease of access to raw materialsYesYesYes (ease of fraudulent activity)
Sophistication of routine testingYesYes (detectability)Yes (sampling programme)
Nature of the raw materialYesYes (product characteristics)
Supply chain complexityYesYes
Supplier relationship and certificationYesIn the supplier assessment

The IFS guideline makes some of the criteria concrete: claims such as organic or a protected designation of origin, and high profit margins, raise risk; risk rises when an adulterant is cheap and easy to obtain; unpackaged bulk product is riskier than pre-packed product; frequent testing by accredited laboratories using accredited methods lowers risk.

Step 5: How is scoring done?

IFS states plainly that it does not prescribe a method, and notes that a decision tree, spreadsheet or matrix can be used. The example in its guideline is a five-by-five matrix: the vertical axis is likelihood of occurrence (fraud history, economic factors, ease of fraudulent activity), the horizontal axis is likelihood of current detection (supply chain complexity, sampling programme, product characteristics). On each axis the highest factor score is taken, and the cell is read as low, medium or high risk. The FSSC guidance suggests a matrix similar to HACCP (likelihood × consequences) and notes that profitability is a key factor in likelihood.

Two cautions matter. According to the FSSC guidance, not every vulnerability is automatically "significant" and not every one requires a mitigation measure, but the method used to decide significance must be documented. Second, the detection axis depends on the business's own controls. The same raw material scores differently when the testing programme changes.

Step 6: What measures are taken for significant vulnerabilities?

BRCGS 5.4.4 requires the plan to include appropriate assurance and/or testing processes for raw materials identified as being at particular risk. The FSSC guidance gives examples of verification: origin and label verification, testing, supplier audits, third-party certification against a GFSI-recognised standard, and specification management.

The IFS guideline treats analytical measures in detail: laboratory accreditation, method and frequency, level of detection, sampling procedure, and batch-related checks at receipt. It includes an important note: if analysis is performed by the manufacturer or supplier, the business should frequently verify those results with its own analysis. We cover how to set that up in our post on supplier certificates of analysis.

Step 7: When is the assessment reviewed?

BRCGS 5.4.3 requires the plan to be reviewed annually and whenever there is a change in raw materials or suppliers, an emerging risk (known adulteration of an ingredient or new scientific information), or a significant product safety incident where authenticity is implicated (for example, a recall). The IFS guideline requires review at least once within a 12-month period and whenever significant changes occur; it lists triggers such as a new supplier, changes in raw material or transport costs, seasonal shortage, non-compliant analysis results and an increase in complaints that may relate to fraud.

What questions does the auditor ask?

The FSSC guidance lists example questions for auditors. They make a useful preparation checklist:

  • Does the team have the right competence and knowledge?
  • Has an assessment been carried out and documented?
  • Are all types of fraud covered: substitution, addition, tampering and misrepresentation?
  • Is the assessment deep enough (historical data, economic motivation, detectability) and does it cover all materials?
  • Is there a method for determining the significance of vulnerabilities?
  • Is there a written plan for significant vulnerabilities, and is it regularly reviewed?

Where does Molevex fit into the assessment?

Molevex contributes to the detection axis and to verification measures. It adds nothing to the product; it measures the raw material's own composition and compares it with a sample you know to be correct. A sample that does not match the profile is taken up in the laboratory, and the result is confirmed there. Because every result is stored linked to its batch, batches from the same supplier can be compared with one another over time, and that record serves as "historical data" at review. You can read about the reference the comparison relies on in our post on the reference library, and find food sector details on the food page. Molevex does not replace official controls or an accredited laboratory report.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between VACCP and TACCP? VACCP looks at fraud for economic gain; TACCP looks at deliberate attacks intended to cause harm (food defence). The FSSC guidance notes that because the motivation differs, food fraud requires a different approach.

Is packaging included in the vulnerability assessment? It depends on the standard. BRCGS 5.4.3 refers to "food raw materials"; the IFS guideline also covers packaging and outsourced processes. The FSSC guidance recommends addressing all products from incoming goods, including packaging materials, to finished product.

Can a ready-made template or tool be used? Yes. The FSSC guidance mentions the free SSAFE tool and notes that the GFSI Board endorses it. Even with a template, the criteria need to be defined for the business's own raw materials.

Does every raw material need laboratory testing? No. The standards call for testing for significant vulnerabilities; for low-risk raw materials, supplier assurance may be judged sufficient. The reasoning for that decision should be written into the assessment.

Is the assessment mandatory under Turkish law? The requirements in this post come from private certification standards. Turkish Law No. 5996 prohibits adulteration and counterfeiting of food; check the current legislation for your business's obligations. This post is not legal advice.

Sources

Meeting request

Let's decide together which of your products to examine.

The first meeting reviews your product, sales channels and the risks you face, and recommends a suitable method.

Request a meeting